Online Cash for Gold Consumer Report & Reviews

Selling your gold isn’t easy. You’ve probably heard some horror stories about a couple companies in the cash for gold industry the past several years, where some mail-in gold services pay you next to nothing for your valuables and basically hold you ransom.

Selling to a local jeweler isn’t much better: you’re at their mercy when evaluating the gold, plus they have to pay expensive overhead to run their business (so they don’t pay you much either).

Despite the bad, there are some honest, reputable online dealers with fair payouts for your gold. To find the best, we sent identical packages to 7 of the top online gold buyers – this website describes our interaction with each company and the amount they offered for the gold.

Our FREE Cash for Gold Company Reports include:

  • Payout: How much did each company offer us?
  • Insurance: How much is your package insured for when sending it?
  • Return period: How long does it take for you to get paid?
  • Shipping: What service do they use? Do they provide you with everything you need?
  • BBB Rating: How trustworthy is the company?
  • Customer Service: Was the company easy to deal with? Were they responsive?
Company NameInsurancePayment AMTBBB
GuaranteeYear In
Check &
Payment Amount

Visit Site
$5000$158.12A30 Days3 Yrs
Read Review
$ 158.12

Visit Site
$5000$146.65A+30 Days12 Yrs
Read Review
$ 146.65

Visit Site
$1000$119.77A+10 Days11 Yrs
Read Review
$ 119.77

Visit Site
$1000$96.85A+15 Days2 Yrs
Read Review
$ 96.85

Visit Site
$2500$75.81A+14 Days19 Yrs
Read Review
$ 75.81

Visit Site
$1000$54.77A-12 Days2 Yrs
Read Review
$ 54.77
Cash for Gold USA
Visit Site
$1000$61.02Not Accredited14 Days6 Yrs
Read Review
$ 61.02

Compare Cash for Gold Companies

gold packages ready to be mailed

See the packaging each company will provide for you to ship your gold & silver.

14k gold rings and silver dollars

We sent each gold buyer an identical 14k gold ring & silver dollar