Gold Buyer Reviews

Reading online gold buyer reviews is important before choosing a cash for gold company. Since online gold buyers pay substantially more than offline jewelers (online jewelers don’t have to pay expensive rents, salaries, security, and other brick-and-mortar costs), it’s smart to sell online – but you’ve got to pick the right company. Our consumer report guides details what it’s like to work with each online cash for gold company.

Company NameInsurancePayment AMTBBB
Rating
GuaranteeYear In
Business
Customer
Reviews
Check &
Payment Amount

Visit Site
$5000$158.12A30 Days3 Yrs
Read Review
$ 158.12

Visit Site
$5000$146.65A+30 Days12 Yrs
Read Review
$ 146.65

Visit Site
$1000$119.77A+10 Days11 Yrs
Read Review
$ 119.77

Visit Site
$1000$96.85A+15 Days2 Yrs
Read Review
$ 96.85

Visit Site
$2500$75.81A+14 Days19 Yrs
Read Review
$ 75.81

Visit Site
$1000$54.77A-12 Days2 Yrs
Read Review
$ 54.77
Cash for Gold USA
Visit Site
$1000$61.02Not Accredited14 Days6 Yrs
Read Review
$ 61.02

Cash for Gold Company Reviews

Our cash for gold reviews are based on the industry test that we executed in early 2012. After sending in identical pieces of gold and silver to 7 different cash for gold companies, we documented the process with each company and the interaction that took place retrieving our items. Not only do you get all the facts on each company, such as their insurance coverage and BBB ratings, you’ll also get the details that you can only get by actually going through the process.

2017 update: We have received several inquiries about Cash for Gold Mailer. We have no plan to do a new test in the near future, but from the research and reviews we’ve seen this seems to be a reputable company.

Take a look through our website to see exactly what kind of packages each company provides, the payouts we received from each one, and probably most importantly – how easy they are to deal with. We sent the gold back to each company to see how easy it was to have our packages returned, so you can read our write-ups and feel confident that if you decide against selling your gold, it won’t be too difficult to get your valuables back.